Vocational experience or a Degree, for management in hospitality?


P4H 2013 the motion: In the current economic climate, vocational experience is more
relevant than traditional academia for a management career in hospitality. 

Wonderful UoB debaters
Jeff,  Sarah and  George.

In a room full of hospitality degree students, academics and industry captains it is quite tough arguing either side of the motion that was put forward to competing teams at the Passion 4 Hospitality 2013 competition.

Yet the two finalist teams from London Metropolitan University and Hotel School the Hague gave it their best with arguments that could sway the audience either way.  However the spirit of the competition can be captured in a single quote from the Hague… the cost of failing in business is more expensive than the cost of your degree…

Of course in the UK unlike the Netherlands the costs for a degree have escalated to dizy heights yet the quote stands true whether we are talking about a 20k debt or a 60k debt .  So many small businesses have found themselves in debts exceeding the 100k mark that having the right knowledge in management is key to their survival.

I guess as an academic and consultant myself I was relieved that in the end The Hague won the argument, I guess we all like it when our existence is justified.

In essence though, the undercurrents of all arguments and the resonating message from both teams (and one that I chose to champion) is that you cant have one without the other and in a world of social media and technological revolution with increasing education choices, it is increasingly easier to both have your cake and eat it!



PS. Thank you to my team from University of Brighton for their hard work and delivering a fantastic presentation in the heats, the organisers at the Instituteof Hospitality and all participating teams and mentors for making yesterday an exceptional day in London, and my congratulations again to the great team from the Hague for wining it as well as The London Metropolitan University team for reaching the finals.

Comments